I took delivery of my demo CG2700X Eizo monitor over the weekend and ran it through its paces; suffice to say I am pretty impressed.
> Phil's technical blog
- Broadcast engineering and IT related links and stuff. Maybe some music, films and other things.
Tuesday, November 08, 2022
The EIZO CG2700X UHD colour accurate monitor
Friday, May 20, 2022
Why I wouldn't buy a Sony BVM-HX310 in 2022 (if it was my money)
I wrote something similar in 2018 - see Why I wouldn't buy a Sony BVM-X300 in 2018 (if it was my money) which was more of a comparison of OLEDs for HDR monitors vs. dual-layer IPS panels (and specifically the gen.1 Eizo Prominence; the CG3145).
Spin forward four years and I'm no longer working for a reseller but doing my own thing (probably a third of which is colour - calibrating and building LUTs) and I've recently become an Eizo reseller myself (full disclosure!).
There are essentially three ways you can hit the requirement for HDR in a monitor - and I am surprised how for some people in the industry it is still an alien concept and yet for others it's 100% required. You have to be able to achieve 1,000 Cd/m2 peak white, a reliable D65 white point, ideally >80% of rec.2020 colour space and the SMPTE 2084 EOTF (the PQ curve), along with HLG and maybe even SLog3 and CLog2 (although those ones are really only occasionally needed on set). BUT, most importantly is good black performance as dynamic range is the difference between the lowest difference that can be faithfully represented and the peak light output. Dolby says this should be > 800,000:1 - you really need those dark, inky blacks.
- OLED - these displays have no trouble with proper blacks (just turn off the sub-pixel elements and no light is output) although the reliability of OLEDs as they approach black is problematic. OLEDs also suffer burn-in - see the 2018 blog for more.
- FALD LCDs - like the Apple XDR and others you can modulate the LED backlight elements in an effort to overcome LCD's failing of letting light leak past the TFT sub-pixels; you can never get good blacks from a single layer LCD (IPS technology or otherwise) so maybe shut-down the light from the backlight when you need black. The problem with this is that the LED backlight array is never as hi-res as the display panel and so at hard black-white transitions you get a halo effect; very noticeable on star-fields and the like. It's why even the very best Samsung TVs don't look as good as LG and Panasonic OLEDs. In the case of the Apple XDR the resolution is nearly 20Mpixels but it has only ~500 modulated backlight elements.
- Dual-layer IPS-LCD - Panasonic manufacture a dual-IPS display assembly (4096x2160 resolution) with backlight that the Sony BVM-HX310 and the Eizo CG3146 Prominence both use. The benefit of having two IPS panels is that any light that leaks through the first will definately be caught by the second. In practise this givens those dark, inky blacks that you normally only get from OLED. Turn off the lights in the room, put up a full-frame black field and you really can't see where the bezel finishes and the screen starts, if you've never seen an LCD doing that well with black you'll be suprised.
- Colour workflow – when I have to calibrate an HX310 (or X300) the client will typically say “…we need to have it ready for 709, DCI-P3, DolbyVision (2084/PQ) and HLG” – with a Sony that is the best part of a morning’s work with lots of adjusting bias and gain values, making measurements and re-adjusting; more akin to a 1990s CRT. The Prominence is an entirely LUT-driven monitor and to set one up for those four standards takes ~15 minutes. Even standards that the monitor does not support out of the box (Clog2 or Slog3 as examples for camera monitoring) can be easily added with ColourSpace by uploading into one of the spare LUT slots. Closed-loop calibration with either ColourSpace or Eizo’s (free) ColourNavigator 7 software is automated and quick (like things should be in the 21st century!)
- Warrantee – the Prominence has a five-year on-site replacement guarantee. If your CG3146 fails four years and eleven months after purchase Eizo will ship a replacement and repair/replace yours free. This includes colour accuracy and faulty pixels (try and get Sony to stand by a two-year-old HX310…!) - I asked my man at Eizo how many times they've had to break out the stand-by monitor; "...we haven't yet had to" - no failed Eizo Prominence monitors in the UK in five years! You can't say that about Sony's.
- Uniformity – I have a customer who has had to send an HX310 back due to poor (i.e. outside EBU 3325 specification) luminance uniformity. The Prominence has Eizo’s DUE (digital uniformity equaliser) which is configured at the factory to give better than delta-0.5 L u’ v’ (as measured on CIE1976) across the whole panel. - here are the measurements taken off an out-of-the-box HX310 a few months ago;
Friday, December 31, 2021
SDi physical layer measurement for 3G and 12G; a video presentation.
Thursday, December 30, 2021
ASUS ProArt PA32UCX monitor - LUTs etc.
My, my; it's been eighteen months since I paid any attention to this blog. Possibly the longest quiet period since I started writing it in 2003! Anyway - it's mostly down to work (I started Media Engineers at the start of 2020; a few weeks before the pandemic started).
Back in 2019 I was approached by ASUS to point a probe at their new PA32U (the first of their 32" monitors to carry the ProArt product name). It had a lot of issues and I wrote up my findings here. I also made a video showing my LightSpace profiling.
- Rec.709 with a gamma of 2.2
- Rec.709 with a gamma of 2.4
- HLG - Rec.2020 colourspace with HLG 1.2
- DolbyVision - ST.2084 curve
- It's a single-layer IPS (LCD) display with an LED backlight,
- It's a FALD (so zone'd backlight) - like the Apple XDR it's an effort to make an LCD have a higher dynamic range. A typical 10-bit LCD panel (like an Eizo CG319X) can achieve about 1,000:1 but with a zone'd backlight that can be in excess of 1,000,000:1 but with the downside of halation around edges and transitions. Compared to dual IPS (think Eizo CG3146 or Sony HX-310) or OLED (typ. Sony X300) it's poor-man's HDR.
- They sell it on the strength of it having "quantum dots"(!) yet it can achieve about the same percentage of DCI-P3 colour space as a modern non-quantum LCD or OLED. If QD actually exists then surely it should approach laser-projector like primary colours and so get close to Rec.2020 colour primaries? Non-intuitively you need monochromatic primaries to be able to get the largest colour-triangle and that's the promise of Quantum Dots - but since this panel does not have monochromatic primaries where are the quantum effects?!
Last thoughts;
- If you put it into HDR mode, then switch the i/p to an SDR signal, disconnect/re-connect (which you have to do) it will then let you recall one of the SDR USER settings (so 1 for 2.4 gamma, 2 for 2.2 gamma) BUT it never takes the backlight back down to SDR levels - so you get rec709 with 500Cd/m2 white. You have to manually wind the "Brightness" figure back from 100 to 10
- "Brightness" is mislabelled - it should be "Backlight" or somesuch
- Brightness is actually called "Black Level"
- Their software proved useless - without ColourSpace I would have been left high and dry.
- All this fiddling about took days (whilst I was doing other things) - I would not want to have been faced with this at a client's site. I won't be taking bookings to calibrate these monitors.
Wednesday, August 05, 2020
JVC DLA-Z1 4k projector; terrible calibration software!
- Spectroradiometers measure wide band light energy - everything from 380nm (or lower) - very deep blue through to 740 (or higher) - very deep red. They are slow to make a reading (many seconds) and do not cope well with low light levels.
- Colourimeters measure just three wavelengths (just like your eyes) - which we'll typically refer to as Red, Green and Blue (but really are X, Y, Z colour matching functions) and so are vulnerable to metameristic failure (a mismatch between the primary colours generated by the display device and the filters used in the colourimeter) BUT they are fast (my Klein K10A can make a read in less than a second) and they are accurate all the way down to near-black.
- Have the probe as close to the screen as possible,
- Have the projector in High LD power mode for at least half an hour,
- Have the video input set for full-range video,
Sunday, May 10, 2020
Kickstarter projects; three out of four ain't bad...
- PockEthernet is a tester for ethernet and IP networks. Serious network people use a Fluke DTX-1800 (I used to have access to one) - it's now discontinued, but like the replacement DSX-series all TDRs (Time Domain Reflectometers) are expensive (a few thousand pounds) but if you want to certify an install it is expected. At the other end of the spectrum you have the £50 DC testers that just make sure there is continuity on each of the eight legs and really just allow you to have some certainty in termination polarity etc. The PockEthernet is a half-way house with some TDR capability (not sure home accurate is it) but nice record keeping. Above a little DC-tester (like a ModTap or others) it can do some IP testing; POE, DHCP, VLAN tags etc. and so for me is ideal.
- BeeLine bike navigator - I often see folks with their smart 'phone in a waterproof wallet as a bike GPS. That's great, but when I'm cycling somewhere I'm not entirely familiar with I often like to find my way but certain in the knowledge that as I get closer I can make better navigation decisions. The BeeLine is a bluetooth attached smart compass that tells you what direction to go and how far your destination is. I've been using mine for maybe eighteen months and it works really well. It is stable and accurate with good battery life.
- Pebble Smart Watch - Although the Apple Watch is undoubtedly a miracle to technology I never felt it was for me; the biggest problem is the battery life; two days at best. It also seems to need a lot of curation. Friends who use them are constantly attending to them and I only really wanted a second screen for my 'phone with good notifications, health tracking and control of media players. The Pebble does just those things really well and nothing else. The battery on mine (Pebble Time Steel variant) lasts for more than a week and when they went bust at the end of 2016 I bought a second one just in case. They charge in about an hour.
- Oscilloscope Watch - I know what you're thinking; what a daft idea! I've written a lot about this one in the past because I did get a very janky alpha-version (3D printed case, very early build of the software etc). Still, five years on and the project is still live on Kickstarter and so we live in hope!
Thursday, March 12, 2020
Modifying Blackmagic 6G routers for quiet(er) operation!
- Cheap, low air volume fans
- Tiny holes in the chassis through which to try and pull enough air
- No control of the fans even though the ones they supply have a tach output
Friday, November 29, 2019
Rigol Ultrascope software and Windows
- Download Ultrascope for your particular series (so DS1000E in my case)
- Download the Windows driver (had to find this on the Way Back Machine!), Extract these two files, then go find the device in the Device Manager. Update the driver and point it to the directory where you extract the driver files.
- Next, download the NI-VISA Run-Time Engine (v5.0.3 as of this writing). Beware, this file weighs in at 71 MB. Install the VISA runtime with the default options (you could probably get away with just installing the USB portion, but I didn’t try it).
- When the NI-VISA installer finally finishes, you might be prompted to reboot. I skipped this step :-). Run the Ultrascope software, and click on Tools –> Connect to Oscilloscope. I was prompted with a list of devices, with none of it making much sense, except the first option “USB0…”